Enron's Fastow points finger at RBC, TD as he heads to jail

"I believe that my work made the company look more healthy and profitable than it actually was. I worked with certain banks to accomplish this goal and I viewed certain banks as problem solvers."

The Globe and Mail
September 27, 2006

Enron's Fastow points finger at RBC, TD as he heads to jail
Ex-CFO accuses several banks of being involved in accounting scam
Sinclair Stewart

In one of his final acts before heading to prison yesterday, former Enron Corp. chief financial officer Andrew Fastow personally implicated a handful of financial institutions —including Royal Bank of Canada and Toronto-Dominion Bank — in the massive accounting fraud that precipitated the energy trader's collapse.

Mr. Fastow was sentenced to six years in prison by a Houston judge for his role in masterminding a series of complex transactions that led to Enron's demise and that ultimately swindled investors out of more than $60-billion (U.S.).

As part of his sentencing hearing, the disgraced executive provided a declaration that could ratchet up the legal fight between the energy traders' investors and several of its former lenders.

Mr. Fastow told lawyers waging a class-action lawsuit on behalf of Enron investors that these banks helped him to devise complex structures that enabled Enron to artificially achieve its financial targets and mask the company's debt.

"I and others, including certain of Enron banks, worked together, intentionally and knowingly, to engage in transactions that would affect Enron's financial statements," he said in the declaration submitted at the hearing yesterday.

"I believe that my work made the company look more healthy and profitable than it actually was. I worked with certain banks to accomplish this goal and I viewed certain banks as problem solvers."

William Lerach, the lawyer leading the class-action effort, suggested yesterday that Mr. Fastow's evidence will help extract lucrative settlements for investors from the company's bankers.

"The testimony provides a clear road map of how the banks were an integral and active player in perpetrating the Enron fraud," he said in an e-mail.

"Fastow's co-operation will help us hold the banks accountable and further our ultimate goal of a substantial recovery for Enron investors."

These investors have already received more than $7.3-billion from numerous settlements, including a record $2.4-billion agreement last year with the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce. Six banks, however, have refused to settle, and one — Barclays Bank PLC — won a major victory in July when a judge removed the British bank from the class-action suit.

Mr. Lerach is trying to have the bank reinstated among the list of defendants for a planned trial next year, but David Braff, a New York lawyer for Barclays, dismissed any notion that Mr. Fastow's testimony might sway the court.

Mr. Braff pointed out that lawyers for the class-action case were among those who asked the judge to extend leniency to the once high-flying Enron official for his co-operation.

"Given the source of the Fastow declaration, and the circumstances of its filing, its credibility is highly suspect," Mr. Braff said.

Mr. Fastow highlighted Merrill Lynch & Co., Credit Suisse First Boston, Royal Bank of Scotland, and Barclays, as among the banks most intimately involved with Enron. Yet he also singled out RBC and TD, two others that have not settled.

Spokesmen for the two banks declined to comment.

Mr. Fastow said that although RBC was only a "Tier-2" lender to the company, he treated it like a "Tier-1" after the bank hired a trio of British investment bankers in 2000 from Greenwich NatWest. He acknowledged he had a "close, personal relationship" with Gary Mulgrew, who along with David Bermingham and Giles Darby have become known as the "NatWest Three."

The men lost a lengthy extradition hearing on fraud charges relating to their former employer, and were recently granted bail by a Houston court.

"I believe that they knew what I expected of RBC, and that they structured transactions at RBC that contributed to causing Enron to manage its balance sheet and generate funds flow from operations," Mr. Fastow stated. He added that he worked with RBC on off-balance sheet arrangements dating back to 1991.

RBC, Canada's largest bank, paid $49-million a year ago to settle a separate legal action in which Enron itself targeted former lenders.

At the time, Enron interim CEO Stephen Cooper provided RBC with an endorsement of sorts, explaining the relatively low sum reflected the fact that RBC "played the smallest role of any of the financial institutions" involved in the Enron affair.

TD received the least attention in Mr. Fastow's declaration. He simply described the bank as a Tier-2 lender, and said it was involved in six "prepay" transactions between 1998 and 2001 that were designed to create "funds flow from operations" at the end of a specific quarter.

Enron engaged in numerous prepay transactions, according to the declaration. These deals made it look as though the company was booking income from selling assets, when in fact it was incurring a future debt to its banks.


Brought to you by WikidFranchise.org

Risks: TD Canada Trust, Royal Bank of Canada, RBC, Banks, Fraud, Enron-like scandals, Lawsuits, class action, Banks allegedly mastermind fraud, Bank stock price seemingly impervious to scandal, Canada, United States, 20060927 Enron's Fastow

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License